Skip navigation

Palace lose first game in five despite dominant performance against Newcastle

Newcastle United
Almirón 83'
Crystal Palace

Roy Hodgson's side can feel disappointed with this afternoon's 1-0 defeat at the hands of Newcastle United, with the Eagles dominating the 90 minutes at St James' Park.

Jordan Ayew Newcastle.jpg

In summary

  • Scott Dann out for the remainder of the year. Kouyaté drops to centre-back
  • James McCarthy comes in. Patrick van Aanholt returns
  • Isaac Hayden rounded Vicente Guaita on six minutes but slipped as he looked like he was about to open the scoring
  • Wilfried Zaha forces good save from Dúbravka on 40 minutes after James McArthur and Christian Benteke worked the opening well
  • Luka Milivojević goes close with free-kick just before half-time
  • HT: 0-0
  • Palace start second-half well – clipped McArthur effort goes just over
  • McArthur has several other decent chances with Palace dominating possession 
  • Last-ditch James Tomkins tackle on Joelinton prevents Magpies taking the lead against the run of play on 67 minutes
  • Miguel Almirón gives Newcastle the lead on 83 minutes
  • FT: 1-0

Crystal Palace started like the home team at St James’ Park with the opening five minutes seeing the Eagles dominate possession in the middle of the park - Jordan Ayew and Christian Benteke’s hold-up play particularly impressive and noticeable.

Despite controlling the start of the game, it was in fact Newcastle United that came closest to scoring in the opening few minutes: Jonjo Shelvey finding his way in to the game with several pinpoint passes and deft control and touches eventually resulted in Isaac Hayden going clean through on six minutes.

Just as the majority of St James’ Park rose in expectation, with Hayden looking like he had rounded Guaita, Mother Nature was on Palace’s side with the wet conditions resulting in the Magpies midfielder slipping just as he looked to slot in to a more or less open goal.

The first-half was falling in to a pattern: Palace dictacting the tempo but Newcastle having the opportunities in front of goal. Steve Bruce’s side’s next chance arrived in the 14th minute when Miguel Almirón bundled his way past Martin Kelly just inside the box but the Paraguayan’s curled effort was easily held by Guaita.

Martin Kelly Miguel Almiron Newcastle.jpg

The flow of the game didn’t look like it was going to alter in the first-half with Newcastle’s next strike on target arriving in the 24th minute following further Palace possession – a speculative 25-yarder from Florian Lejeune testing Guaita due to the wet conditions rather than the fierceness of the strike.

Palace’s first chance of the game arrived a third in to the game, with an inviting cross from Van Aanholt finding the head of Christian Benteke. However, the striker’s header bounced just wide of Martin Dúbravka’s goal.

Benteke Header Newcastle.jpg

The effort from Benteke provoked further Palace pressure. A well-worked move on the edge of the box between McArthur and Benteke released Zaha inside the right channel of the Magpies’ penalty box. Zaha’s low, hard effort forced a good save from Dúbravka as the Eagles pushed for the opener before half-time. And it so nearly came from the captain Milivojević with a free-kick that looked to have Dúbravka troubled but curled just past the post.

Zaha shot Newcastle.jpg

Palace carried on where they ended the first-half, with Van Aanholt cutting the Magpies’ defence apart with an incisive pass through to McArthur. However, the midfielder’s attempted deft chip over Dúbravka clipped the ‘keeper and landed just over the bar.

Palace continued to play intricate, well-controlled football that tended to result in McArthur having an effort on goal. The Scotsman started the next exciting exploit forward: a long-range pass picking out a clever off the ball run from Van Aanholt behind Javier Manquillo. Van Aanholt turned back to find Zaha who created a neat opening for McArthur, however the midfielder was losing his footing just as he looked to fire home and the ball trickled through to Dúbravka.

James McArthur chip Newcastle.jpg

Palace’s continued pressure saw Steve Bruce try to stem the flow of the Eagles by bringing on Sean Longstaff for Hayden on 64 minutes. And three minutes later the personnel change almost paid dividends with Joelinton going through, however, as he has done so often in his Palace career, James Tomkins made an immaculate last-ditch tackle to thwart the danger.

Former Eagle Dwight Gayle entered the fray on 77 minutes for Newcastle as Bruce continued to try and find a way to tip the balance of the game in his Magpies' favour. And six minutes later Geordies had the lead through Almirón, who blasted home from the centre of the box on 83 minutes.

Hodgson responded to going a goal down by bringing on Max Meyer for McArthur, with the German instrumental in earning Palace a point earlier in the week against Brighton & Hove Albion when he entered proceedings. However, it wasn't to be for Palace who return to south London without anything to show for their dominant display.

Palace: Guaita, Kelly, Kouyate, Tomkins, Van Aanholt, McCarthy, McArthur [Meyer 86], Milivojevic, Zaha, Benteke, Ayew.

Subs Not Used: Hennessey, Woods, Daly, Pierrick, Riedewald, Wickham.

Newcastle: Dúbravka, Dummett, Fernández, Schär, Manquillo, Joelinton [Gayle 77], Hayden [S. Longstaff 64], Shelvey, Almirón [Yedlin 90+1], Lejeune, Carroll.

Subs Not Used: Darlow, Krafth, M.Longstaff, Atsu.