The forward earned the award with 32.5% of the vote - just edging out Cheikhou Kouyate to first place, with the makeshift centre-back collecting 30%.
Goalscorer Jeffrey Schlupp picked up 18% of the vote to finish third place. Schlupp's driven run to net the game's sole goal resembled one made by Ayew just moments before, and it was the striker's determination over 90 minutes which saw fans select him for Man of the Match.
You can watch how the lads fared below in our cut-down highlights. For longer highlights from the evening, head to Palace TV now!