With two goalscorers, a penalty save and a whole host of heroic displays in Saturday's 2-2 draw, this decision was likely to be as difficult as ever.
And so the case proved, with three contenders all within 2.6% of one another's polling scores with supporters.
Henderson came out on top with 23.9% of fans' votes, making a number of huge stops including a fine springing save to deny Youri Tielemans from the spot – seconds before Ismaila Sarr teed up Justin Devenny, who scored 23.3% and 21.9% of votes respectively.
Both players scored their first Premier League goals for Palace at Villa Park, with Maxence Lacroix also impressing fans and scoring 19.1% in the poll.
See the full results of the Player of the Match poll below!